Pizza Heaven
Welcome to Pizza Heaven, where the art of pizza-making meets heavenly flavors! Situated at 357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600 in New Windsor, NY, this pizzeria is a paradise for food enthusiasts. Our menu is a delightful blend of traditional recipes and innovative toppings, designed to cater to both classic preferences and adventurous eaters. At Pizza Heaven, we use the highest quality ingredients, from our homemade dough to our rich sauces, ensuring that each pizza is a masterpiece. The inviting atmosphere, combined with friendly service, makes it an ideal spot for all occasions—whether it's a cozy family meal, a fun night out with friends, or a quick lunch break. Our dedication to quality and taste has made us a favorite in the community, and we’re excited to share our passion for pizza with you! Visit Pizza Heaven today and experience for yourself a slice of culinary delight that you won’t soon forget.
Nearby Places to Explore
Nearby Events
Services
Amenities
Accessibility
Payment Options
Parking Options
Location & Map
Find this place on Google Maps and get turn-by-turn directions before you go.
Google Reviews
h dBeautiful Resturant. Great customer service. Excellent food. Premium ingredients. 10/10 The food was so good I almost forgot to snap a flick of the lasagna slice. Darlene was amazing. Customer Service that makes you feel home.
Apr 28, 2026 · Google Review
Ray MelnikStopped in once. Now I do a few times a month. Great pizza, super friendly staff, good location. Home of the large slice!
Jun 9, 2026 · Google Review
Jim LeaskeyIt was one of a dozen restaurants in a half mile radius, and the reviews looked favorable. Upon arrival, I noticed the pizza by the slice displays were empty due to being cleaned. After placing our order for a whole pizza, a regular came in and asked about the slices. I overheard the conversation, and there were at least 6 different pizza options on the back counter. Boy, did we miss out. Pizza by the slice is the way to go. Now about the pizza. Just what you would expect for NY style pizza. Dough was thin and cooked to perfection. Git a large and bottled drinks for under $30. G The last item was the garlic knots. Knew right away when they were being prepped for cooking. Then when they went in the oven, all you could smell was garlic. I would have liked to get some, but pizza was plenty for the 2 of us. Check the box and would recommend you stop and decide for yourself.
Jul 20, 2024 · Google Review
Kristina LewisMe and my aunt were there today to get the large pizza slices, they were so delicious as usual today makes my 2nd time going there, excellent pizza, the staff and owner are very friendly. I can’t wait to come back🫶🏽
Jun 4, 2026 · Google Review
Rachel Milito your RealtorWOW !!! The slices of pizza here are massive!! It really is PIZZA HEAVEN. They are more then double of what a normal slice usually is. My nephew and I popped in for a quick slice in between his taekwondo classes. Pizza was delicious as well. The staff is super friendly and the restaurant is very clean and comfortable ! Thanks for a great dinner !!! We will be back 🙂
Oct 22, 2019 · Google Review