Columbus Hotel

Bed And Breakfast, Lodging, Point of Interest52 Cottage St, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

4.2

Unfortunately, we cannot recommend this property based on our experience. We booked the Airbnb the same day and arrived that evening fully intending to stay. However, what we encountered upon arrival made us uncomfortable enough that we chose to leave immediately and find somewhere else to stay. When we arrived, there was police activity in the immediate area and an individual outside the building whose behavior made us very uncomfortable. The overall surroundings and our experience arriving at the property were not what we had anticipated based on the listing, and we did not feel comfortable entering the building or staying there overnight. I want to be clear that I am describing our personal experience and what we personally observed upon arrival. Other guests may feel differently, but had we understood what the immediate surroundings and arrival experience would be like, we would not have booked this property. We contacted the host immediately to explain why we were leaving. Unfortunately, we found the response to our concerns to be dismissive and lacking in empathy. Rather than acknowledging why guests arriving to these circumstances might reasonably be concerned, the focus of the response was repeatedly on the fact that our discomfort was a “personal” decision. We ultimately left without staying at or using the property at all. I wish we had seen a review describing this type of arrival experience before booking, which is why I feel it is important to share ours. Future guests can decide for themselves what they are comfortable with, but based on our experience, we would not book this property again. Similar reviews can be found on the Expedia platform.

Google Reviews

Michael Dayton

#michaeldayton

Jun 30, 2026 · Google Review

Nearby Places to Explore

2 miles range

Main Menu

Quick Links

Columbus Hotel

Columbus Hotel

Nearby Places to Explore

San Cristobal

Restaurante Mexicano

Clemson Bros. Brewery

Thrall Park

Downtown Village

Quinnz Pinz

La Morenita Market- Mexican Restaurant

Perla Escondida Mexican Restaurant

Latino Restaurant Inc

Taqueria San Miguelito Inc

Orange County Heritage Trail

The Switch Inn

Los Mocanos Restaurant

Garden Dynasty

El Azteca Mexican Restaurant

Number 1 Chinese Restaurant

Taco Veloz

La Esquina

El Punto Lounge & Bar

Sara Bakery

Nelsons Bar

Jackie's Latin Kitchen

Milo's Restaurant

Oak & Reed

North Wind Bread Company

The Taco Factory

De Filippis Bakery

King’s Bake & Brew

DAYES Coffee Roasters

3 Ninja Express

La FATA’s Eatery

Sister's Island Cuisine

Mister Croissant Bakery & Cafe

Piccolo Cucina e Vino

Edwin Welling Van Duzer Memorial House

El Zapata

MFC Gyro & Grill Halal

Rock Fantasy

North King Centre

Well Worn Books

Nearby Events

Rock, Roll & Run Weekend

City of Middletown's Summer Concert Series - Thursdays

Super Mario Track Tuesdays @ Equilibrium Brewery

Middletown BID Farmers' Market

City of Middletown's Summer Concert Series - Fridays

Men of Soul

Live and Let Die - A Symphonic Tribute to Paul McCartney

Dr. Temple Grandin

Funny Women of a Certain Age

The Spinners

Pat Farrell And The Cold Spring Harbor Band

Jessica Lynns A Very Merry Classic Christmas

Arts and Culture Festival

Location & Map

Book Your Stay In Orange County, NY