A D

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

**ETA** we have been back weekly over the last 5 or so weeks and this is our new favorite pizza place. Service is always top notch and very friendly, and everything we have tried from the menu has been delicious. Highly recommend. ......... Service was amazing. We tried a mix of food (pizza, meatball parm sub, fries, fried dough) all of which were delicious. Price point was good and the building is neat. Would definitely recommend. The pepperoni has a little kick to it, so if you like a non-spicy pepperoni, may want to avoid that

Carrie Taveirne

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

We started with the garlic knots which were fantastic! Then the large pizza with two sides of options. Best Pizza I've had since I lived in Jersey in 2001. Took Zitti to go too. It was cooked and seasoned to perfection! Will absolutely go back! The service made us feel like family!

Human Being in the World, just like you

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

April 15th, 2026 Today, I had the pleasure of walking into Pizza Plus for the first time, alongside my partner. We're both locals in the area and were looking for a place to eat after a nature walk nearby. On both a time and budget crunch, Pizza Plus was the spot - both convenient and a short trip from our walk, and it had all the usual pizza dishes and pizza dish alternatives that you would normally find at other pizzerias. What set Pizza Plus apart was its homey atmosphere and welcoming staff. Me and my partner were greeted by Leanne, who went through and explained the pizza options we were curious about. After me and my partner both made our choices, I specifically requested for the dishes to not be served too hot. As we took a seat, Leanne brought our dishes over exactly how I'd asked. While we were eating, I'd overheard some customer interactions that Leanne took over the phone and discussed with the family members of the establishment behind the counter in the prep and baking areas. It seemed as though the customer on the phone was giving them a hard time; and as someone who works in a high-risk, customer-facing industry (not food service however), I naturally sympathized with them and how they discussed their interaction(s) with the customer on the phone. While some crude language was being exchanged, it only seemed normal as per the difficult order. However that turned out, I continued observing. Leanne and the other family members still fulfilled the order and took the time to bundle the food nicely, and as other restaurants usually do, include their menu in the bag along with the order. The atmosphere. Where do I start? The location is somewhat hidden and I almost missed the turn; not the most ideal nor optimal, tucked in a corner in the back of a one-way small strip parking lot with 2 hour time limits in front of sidelining businesses - that then also branches into two other parking lots for other purposes. Where do I park that I don't risk getting a ticket from Crawford Police?... I will still keep the high rating and not deduct any stars however - bear with me here. You walk into a hallway, and at first you're confused. On one side, there is a trading card game hall. Me and my partner were slightly confused as to where Pizza Plus was. Then I turned around and saw the double door entrance. It was hidden; and I had a bit of trouble getting into the entrance, not clear on the push or pull aspect, if I had to turn the door knob, etc. (Could just be me, but still, slightly confusing). Apart from Leanne and her family's service walking in where we were also smiled at by one of the oven guys in the family when he returned from the bathroom, I also took note of and observed the small environment inside. The first thing you see before meeting Leanne's face and welcome, along the wall is Pizza Plus's various plaques of excellence recognition. It goes to show their commitment to service and a passion in their food. When you take a seat, the temperature is regulated well. It was a hot day, 85+ degrees; both me and my partner, sweating - like dogs: especially fresh off of a nature trail. We cooled off quick as we waited to be served our food. I took note of their wall decor: rustic accentuation with farm/prairie artwork, alongside a banner that read something along the lines of "Good Vibes. Good Friends. Good People." (Don't remember the exact wording, but it said "Good" 3 times, in short sentences like that.) As I wrap up my thorough review, I hope that Pizza Plus will continue to remain in the hands of a family that loves what they do and takes pride in it, serving good food - with good vibes, good friends, and good people!

Dawn stoughton

3 out of 5 stars★★★☆☆

Ordered take out.pizza was decent, meatball Parm hero excellent, dozen wings horrible!! Smelled bad, and extremely dried out. It was daily special. On the menu online says that bottle of soda was included wasn't cost me $44 and change delivery was fast. The fact that it was advertised for $29 for a large pie wings and a bottle of 2 l bottle of soda , and it was a medium pie no soda and wings that were inedible.