Noble Pies - Greenwood Lake
Nestled in the picturesque Greenwood Lake, Noble Pies at 122 Windermere Avenue is your go-to destination for an unforgettable culinary experience. Our bakery prides itself on offering a mouthwatering variety of homemade pies, each one a testament to our dedication to quality and flavor. From the moment you step inside, the sweet aroma of freshly baked goods welcomes you, making it a haven for pie lovers of all ages. Whether you're planning a cozy family dinner, a picnic by the lake, or simply seeking a delightful treat, Noble Pies has something special for everyone. Our inviting atmosphere and passionate staff are here to ensure that your visit is not just about enjoying delicious pies, but also about creating wonderful memories. Stop by for a taste of joy today and discover why we are a beloved staple in the Greenwood Lake community.
Nearby Places to Explore
Nearby Events
Services
Amenities
Accessibility
Payment Options
Location & Map
Find this place on Google Maps and get turn-by-turn directions before you go.
Google Reviews
Patricia HoranThey went out of their way to make a last minute peanut Butter Cream pie for my hubby's birthday. Went the extra mile and wrote Happy Birthday on it for him. It tasted even better than usual because of the caring put into it. Great people. Terrific business.
Mar 17, 2026 · Google Review
Traveling GuideThis gem of a bakery specializes in small-batch, handcrafted pies that elevate the humble dessert to an art form. Let me address the elephant in the room right away: yes, these pies come with a premium price tag. But after one bite, you’ll understand why they’re absolutely worth the investment. What sets this shop apart is their commitment to quality over quantity. Each pie is made in small batches with obvious care and attention to detail. You can taste the difference that fresh, high-quality ingredients and traditional techniques make. This isn’t your grocery store pie – this is what pie is supposed to taste like. The seasonal rotation of offerings is my only minor gripe, though I can hardly fault them for it. This approach actually ensures you’re getting fruit at its peak freshness and flavor. Sure, it means you can’t always get your favorite variety year-round, but it also means each season brings something special to look forward to. Now, let me talk about the stars of the show: the cherry and blueberry pies are nothing short of spectacular. The cherry pie strikes that perfect balance between tart and sweet, with plump, juicy cherries that burst with flavor. The blueberry is equally divine – the filling is generous and perfectly spiced, letting the natural sweetness of the berries shine through. And that crust? Flaky, buttery perfection that practically melts in your mouth. If you’re a pie enthusiast or just someone who appreciates exceptional baked goods, this shop is an absolute must-visit. Just be prepared to spoil yourself for ordinary pies forever.
Nov 23, 2025 · Google Review
Jena VignolaI ordered a pie from here for Thanksgiving on the recommendation of a friend. I ordered the Will You Marry Me Cherry with the crumble crust. Since the place is 30 min from me, I asked to pick up the day before. The girl took my phone number and said they would let me know when it's ready for pick up. I tried to call all day Tues and Wed morning to confirm when I could come (since it was not a local trip for me). No one answered the phone so I just headed there. When I got there, they had all the pies ready and I don't think I needed to wait for a phone call, so I'm not sure why she told me that. Just miscommunication, I guess, but then the pie crust was also not correct. Luckily, they found another one with the correct crust, so hopefully this didn't mess up someone else's order. Regardless, the servers were extremely friendly and helpful and were working really hard to get all the orders ready. The pie was good but the cherries were very tart. I should have asked before I ordered, but I was expecting a sweeter pie. I may try the apple or a different flavor next time. It was $34 for s 9" pie.
Dec 10, 2025 · Google Review
maislocodomondo ghibuorHad the apple pie, delicious! We'll try another one tomorrow 😁
Aug 9, 2026 · Google Review