Brothers Barbecue
Step into Brothers BBQ, the ultimate destination for barbecue lovers in New Windsor, NY! Situated at 2402 NY-32, this vibrant restaurant offers a warm and welcoming environment where friends and family can gather to enjoy a variety of delicious smoked meats. At Brothers BBQ, every dish is made with passion and care, ensuring that each bite is a burst of flavorful goodness. With a menu featuring succulent ribs, perfectly smoked brisket, and savory pulled pork, there’s something to please every palate. Don't forget to complement your meal with our signature sides and homemade sauces for an authentic BBQ experience! Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Brothers BBQ promises quality food and exceptional service that will leave you coming back for more. Join us and discover why we are the go-to barbecue spot in town!
Nearby Places to Explore
Nearby Events
Services
Amenities
Accessibility
Payment Options
Parking Options
Location & Map
Find this place on Google Maps and get turn-by-turn directions before you go.
Google Reviews
Jose RodriguezThis place is soooo good. Me and my family have gone to alot of BBQ spots up and down the east coast (from Boston to Miami) and this is top 3.. it's hard to have all 6 of us love everything, NO complaints about anything. Corn bread was great, pulled pork amazing,brisket out if this world, and best of all our server Alex (from Missouri) was an absolute gem. Most definitely recommended..
Sep 7, 2026 · Google Review
Blue beardVery good bbq and the staff is great.
Sep 6, 2026 · Google Review
Don SileoAlways great food and our waitress, Rachel, was absolutely the BEST! She was friendly and fun! We look forward to coming back and seeing her!
Sep 1, 2026 · Google Review
Selma BenitezBritney service was amazing 👏 🤩
Aug 30, 2026 · Google Review
Eileen CliffordAwesome sauce! Brittany was a terrific server 5 🌟 stars for everything!
Aug 28, 2026 · Google Review
Janet HooverThis is the best BBQ we have ever had. It is about 30 mins from our house but it is well worth the drive. I get their baby back ribs which be sure to ask for them to be caramelized as it gives them a crispier glazed texture. They are fall off the bone goodness!! Not only that, each rib has lots of meat on them. I usually can only get through 2 maybe 3 ribs but it’s great cause I get another meal from the leftovers. The ribs come with your choice of 2 sides which there are so many to choose from. I get their baked beans and candied yams. Both are amazing! My husband loves their brisket. We also have had their burgers which are so delicious. They are a blend of meats which makes them very flavorful and juicy. The fries are to die for. My husband and I can’t have gluten, egg or soy but there are plenty of options for us. Unfortunately we can’t have the cornbread but our sons tell us that it is really good. When they come up from the city we always make a trip here to get some good BBQ. Like I said this is the best BBQ ever. Update: recently they told me that they only have the baby back ribs on the weekends. I was saddened to hear this as we like to go to restaurants during the week to avoid crowds. So if you want baby back ribs don’t go during the week. 😢.
Aug 27, 2026 · Google Review
fr ValentinCornbread was delicious. Mac and cheese was delicious. Aunt Edna’s fried chicken was freshly fried and juicy. Service was great and the music was on point! Hank asked us how our honest experience was and after sharing that we were hesitant to order the brisket, he made sure to get us a sample. I’m glad he did because it was so tender and juicy. Paired with their homemade bbq sauce was perfect. Will definitely be returning!
Aug 21, 2026 · Google Review
Mina wilkinsonEverything we ate was awesome! We had the “eat like a king” feast and it didn’t disappoint. Free soda refills and the cup size was generous! Even one of the Brothers (owner) came to make sure everything was going good and even filled us in on his rich family history. Definitely will go again!!!!
Aug 17, 2026 · Google Review
