Annabel's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Italian cuisine, pizza, stromboli, pasta, and more. Open 7 days a week 10am – 10pm.
Facebook: Annabel’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Nearby Places to Explore
Nearby Events
Services
Amenities
Accessibility
Payment Options
Parking Options
Location & Map
Find this place on Google Maps and get turn-by-turn directions before you go.
Google Reviews
I visit this place everytime I’m in the area for food and it’s time to leave a review after my 5th visit! Always greeted respectfully by whoever is working the counter! Always get the pizza and occasionally the garlic knots and it’s delicious. The slices are big and heavy but it’s not a bad thing! You expect it to taste like dough since it’s such a thick slice but honestly it has amazing crunch of a thin slice the sauce is delicious and flavorful and the cheese is perfect. The garlic knots are flavorful and evenly coated. The price is extremely reasonable and the bathroom is clean! Iv tried other shops in the area and to be honest this place blows them away by far! From the highest level of respect, to delicious affordable food options, and a clean place to eat and use the rest room. This place is amazing. I look forward to trying something that isn’t just pizza. Thank you guys for the high level performance!
May 5, 2026 · Google ReviewGreat food, nice people, I just wish they had delivery available. They also have outdoor seating that is great during the summer. I haven't gotten anything from them that I didn't like. 10/10! I highly recommend this place if you are in the area!
Mar 19, 2026 · Google Reviewthe pizza is on par with the best in NY- as good or better than Grimaldis and John’s on Bleeker. The service was friendly and we are still in awe of how incredibly delicious the pizza was- extra cheese and pepperoni- one of the best we have ever had anywhere in the world
Jun 3, 2026 · Google ReviewStopped in for dinner while on a short trip, staying just around the corner at an AirBnB on High Street (Unionville). With very little restaurant choice in the region, it was nice to have this place so close by. This restaurant was a high 3, low 4 stars. We ordered garlic knots, buffalo wings, a slice of pizza, a ham and turkey sub, and two cannolis (one chocolate dipped). The garlic knots were great, hard to mess up. The wings were below average to me, but that's coming from a spoiled Rochester, NY perspective. They reminded me of what we could buy from a grocery store as frozen, fully cooked and sauced chicken wings. We tried the tortellini alfredo pizza slice, good overall, the crust was a tad weak (again spoiled by Rochester). The sub was average as well. The cannolis were nice and fresh, a good ending to the meal. Apologies for the poor photo quality on a few shots (camera had a smudge on it for a short time). The staff made up for the average meal; very outgoing, friendly, and helpful, pushing this review to the 4 stars. The interior was brightly decorated and we were the only ones dining in. The bathroom was average.
Feb 26, 2021 · Google Review










